Trottier, Maxine. 2011. Migrant. Berkeley, CA:
Groundwood Books. Ill. by Isabelle Arsenault.
ISBN 978-0-88899-975-7
B. PLOT SUMMARY
Every spring Anna and her family travel from Mexico to Canada searching for work on farms. Anna feels like a bird flying north for the spring, or a kitten curled up with her sisters, and wonders what it would feel like to be a tree with deep roots.
C. CRITICAL ANALYSIS (INCLUDING CULTURAL MARKERS)
Anna's story offers cultural markers which connect the plight of the migrant worker to stationary society. Use of imagery and metaphors conveys a child's perception of life and sense of longing for stability and continuity. The author's comparison to of the life of a migrant child to animals and common plants brings the life of migrant farm workers into an understandable place which all can draw comparisons. Language differences are addressed through the common experience of shopping for groceries and the sounds of raised voices are compared to a chorus of crickets chirping different songs.
Illustrations by Isabelle Arsenault help to depict cultural differences. The traditional clothing of the Mennonites are starkly different from those of the stationary citizens of the town to which Anna and her family travel. And the colors and patterns of the landscape and animals mimic the traditional and old fashioned quality of Mennonite quilts.
The plight of the migrant farm worker is presented in a manner which allows others to correlate the experiences in a way that is meaningful to them on a personal level. The presentation of feelings and questions throughout the text forces the reader to put themselves in the place of Anna and imagine the differences in lifestyle.
D. REVIEW EXCERPTSGovernor General's Award: Illustration, 2011, Short-listed, Migrant.
New York Times Best Illustrated, 2011, Commended, Migrant.
ALA Notable Chilren's Books List, 2012, Commended, Migrant.
2012 USBBY Outstanding International Book, 2012, Commended, Migrant.
2012 Notable Books for a Global Society Book Award , 2012, Winner, Migrant.
Amelia Frances Howard-Gibbon Illustrator’s Award Honour Book, 2012, Winner, Migrant.
6th Annual ReadBoston Best Read Aloud Book Award., 2012, Short-listed, Migrant.
Ruth and Syliva Schwartz Children's Picture Book Award, 2012, Short-listed, Migrant.
The words and images could stand alone as feats of artistic excellence. Together, they form a package that should become a staple for kids learning about Canada’s diverse population.
"...moving, inventive and thoughtful..."
E. CONNECTIONSChildren can investigate the life of migrant farm workers through internet and government resources.ALA Notable Chilren's Books List, 2012, Commended, Migrant.
2012 USBBY Outstanding International Book, 2012, Commended, Migrant.
2012 Notable Books for a Global Society Book Award , 2012, Winner, Migrant.
Amelia Frances Howard-Gibbon Illustrator’s Award Honour Book, 2012, Winner, Migrant.
6th Annual ReadBoston Best Read Aloud Book Award., 2012, Short-listed, Migrant.
Ruth and Syliva Schwartz Children's Picture Book Award, 2012, Short-listed, Migrant.
The words and images could stand alone as feats of artistic excellence. Together, they form a package that should become a staple for kids learning about Canada’s diverse population.
- Quill & Quire, starred review
Without a heavy message, this sensitive offering captures a small child’s experience of constant upheaval as she flies like a feather in the wind.
- Booklist
"...moving, inventive and thoughtful..."
- Kirkus Reviews
http://www.ncfh.org/?sid=34
http://www.doleta.gov/msfw/
Science connection: students can learn about migratory patterns of birds.
Art connection: Have students make a "flying geese" quilt http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/home/flying-geese-variation-quilt-block.htm
Look for these other books for young people about migrant farmworkers:
Atkin, S.B. (2000). Voices from the Fields : Children of Migrant Farmworkers Tell Their Stories. ISBN 978-0316056205
Dorros, A. (1997). Radio Man. ISBN-13: 978-0064434829
Buirski, N. (1994). Earth Angels: Migrant Children in America. ISBN-13: 978-0876540732
Look for this other books about Mennonites:
Hiebert, C. (2003). Us Little People. ISBN 978-1550462722
No comments:
Post a Comment